Saturday, December 9, 2017

ESSAY: When we can't talk politics

“We’ll never solve the problems we don’t talk about.”
 ~Justin Young

An odd couple / Cindy La Ferle

This essay was originally published in December 2016. Excerpts from another version appeared in one of my newspaper columns. ~CL 

While clearing out the planters and perennial beds, my husband found the small gnome, in the photo above, buried in a tangle of expired morning glories. Setting the little guy next to a garden angel on the window sill, Doug didn't realize that he'd gifted me with a photo opportunity -- and inspired a philosophical reverie.

As soon as I noticed the unlikely pair perched together, I thought about the tact and discernment it takes to find common ground with people who don't share our point of view. And then I thought about how our nation has become so tribal and polarized on matters of politics and policy. 

I've been struggling, unsuccessfully, to come to terms with this awkward divide in my own social life. With the exception of my closest friends, everyone else seems to be avoiding the difficult political conversations. 

The safest thing to do, of course, is to stick with non-controversial topics. This makes perfect sense if you're trying to maintain professional boundaries with colleagues and coworkers -- or you'd simply rather keep acquaintances or relatives at a cordial distance. 

But as any good therapist will tell you, the things we don't talk about might be the invisible obstacles that stand in the way of creating deeper intimacy in our relationships. 

In other words, self-disclosure is key. When we hide our problems, withhold our opinions, and never discuss our core values, our relationships will likely remain superficial or transient. Speaking for myself, I've noticed that the things I can talk about -- or can't talk about -- are a measure of the depth (or limitations) of each of my friendships. 

I'm equally guilty of practicing avoidance techniques. 

Over the past year, I've had in-depth political discussions only with my trusted tribe -- the friends with whom I feel safe, validated, and comfortable. Whenever I'm the least bit unsure of someone's political stance, I tend to soft-pedal my viewpoints or avoid discussing them out of fear of being judged or shamed -- which has happened often enough to discourage me. Whether we want to admit it or not, it's human nature to gravitate toward others who mirror our beliefs, values, and politics -- not just our hobbies or interests. Sometimes we have to dig deeper to find common ground.

I know this is a painful topic. And I'm not promoting hostile or confrontational discussion. Instead, I'm talking about opening our hearts and minds to each other on a deeper level. As sociologist Brene Brown writes in Daring Greatly: How the Courage to Be Vulnerable Transforms the Way We Live, Love, Parent, and Lead: "Courage starts with showing up and letting ourselves be seen." 

I enjoy few things more than engaging with fair-minded people who are willing to discuss the important stuff -- the big issues. I want to know what my friends and family are thinking about current events, local and national leaders, and more. I want to understand the moral compass that guides them, how they study the issues, what they're reading and watching, how they make difficult choices, and what truly matters to them politically as well as personally. 

On Sundays, my husband and I make sure we read at least two opinion pieces written by newspaper columnists who don't share our political views. At the very least, we might admire their writing or learn to view an issue from another angle we hadn't considered. 

Today, more than ever, the political is personal. I'm willing to listen and learn -- even when I'm not in agreement with what I'm hearing. 

Our country is in deep crisis. If we can't even begin to talk about it, well, I guess I'll have to leave it at that. ~Cindy La Ferle

______________________
As always, you are welcome to share my posts on social media. Please click on one of the social media options in the beige box located below this post.

9 comments:

  1. Beautifully written. Thank you so much for opening up your heart and sharing this thought provoking article.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I enjoy your perspective, Cindy. We DO need to talk openly and broadly. And we also need to READ openly and broadly. And then talk about what we read. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment, Claire. I always learn so much from you and admire how well-informed you are!

      Delete
  3. Totally agree with your insightful blog, Cindy. This is why my daily media diet includes those outlets where I feel like an outsider. Just being aware of others' objections to my values and beliefs is important and a step in the right direction. Every day I try to become more comfortable with being uncomfortable as I dive into how others think. But it needs to work both ways. The good news is that more and more of my friends and acquaintances tell me "I've never been so politically aware." That's a good start....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Theresa, what great points you make! I too try to read the opposing viewpoints in order to learn *why* some people disagree with things I believe in. It's hard to push beyond on our comfort zones, but there will be no real peace for any of us if we don't at least make an effort. I like what you said about people being more politically aware now. But being politically aware means being aware of all sides of an issue -- as you pointed out.

      Delete
  4. Love the photo, love your words.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nancy, thank you -- I miss you!! Drop me an email and let me know how you are, please?

      Delete
  5. Terrific post, Cindy. I totally agree! We can all learn from others. We just need to listen! This increased information and insight helps us make more informed decision. The key is not to let it get into an argument.

    ReplyDelete